York Whisky Club

Join fellow whisky lovers based in & around York

Tasting #16 – No Bells, Just Whistles (24/2/24)

We promised to rewrite our collective history of drinking underwhelming blends from parental cupboards in our formative years.

And consensus was ….. we delivered!

  1. Michel Couvreur Overaged French Malt Whisky (43%, £90.78)
  2. Cadenhead Blended Scotch Whisky 25 Years (41.4%, £70)
  3. Mossburn 12 Year Old Speyside Blended Malt Foursquare Rum Finish (57.9%, £65)
  4. The Cooper’s Choice Campbeltown 9 Year Old 2014 (cask 1133) (53%, £80) – Master of Malt have this discounted to £75.06 (link)
  5. Wemyss Malts – Spice King Highland & Islay 12 year old Whisky (52%, £37.95)
  6. Compass Box Duality (54%, £180) – Not currently on sale, may return on the Compass Box website (this link).


We started with Michel Couvreur Overaged Malt Whisky, a NAS expected to be 12yrs+ (could be much older) taken from Scotland & racked in sherry casks in Burgundy caves for a few years of 🇫🇷 ‘over maturation’. This wasn’t a contender for dram of the night, but in the social drams afterwards, feedback was that this won ‘most intriguing’. Quite a bit of flip-flopping as to whether we’d pay the £90 RRP.

A Cadenhead Enigma 25yr blend followed with a ‘Walnuts, church pews, caramel’ nose suiting our location in St Crux. More 🧡 for this than the first (good value for £70/41.4%) but that was about to be blown away…

By a Mossburn 12 Year Old Speyside Blended Malt, a collaboration with Foursquare Rum🍹 that romped to dram of the night with over half the votes. This is the start of an annual Cask Collaboration Series where Mossburn blend / finish a different Scotch using barrels sourced from a distillery across different spirit categories. Very tropical 🌴 fruit, a tasty cask strength (57.7%) & a great price point (£65), much 🥃❤️.

A teaspooned Sauternes cask Campbeltown from The Cooper’s Choice (£80/53%) stretched the blend theme & piqued interest, but not as much as our final two…

We headed north to Highlands & Islay with a Wemyss Malts – Spice King 12 year old, intrigued by the ‘herbaceous smoke’ finish, a new descriptor for the club, which was a snip at £37.95 (52% ABV).

We then rounded off the night with Compass Box Duality, a smoky Ardbeg combined with a PX-matured Bimber whisky. Bottled at 54% ABV, the release has an RRP of £180 with 1,050 bottles available (now 1,049). Huge 🙏 to Compass Box for providing a great blend which we thought gave a smoother, more refined Ardbeg experience.

The use of the entrance to St Crux by ghost tours meant we had to turn away a few looking for the wrong type of spirits 👻 but those correctly hunting for 🥃 weren’t disappointed & we were touched to get feedback like “You’ve done it again, super interesting tasting!”